Teaching IPA in a dialectally diverse classroom

That sounds very pompous as a title. But I’ve been thinking about this recently because of teaching intro linguistics. We have been talking about IPA and English transcription, and in particular we’ve had a lot of discussion about English back vowels.

Now, the students learn IPA and something about phonetics before we talk about phonemes, and before anything much about dialectal variation and sociolinguistics. We’ve had quite a bit of confusion. I have fairly standard Australian English vowels (although maybe my back vowels are a bit more rounded than standard, and my diphthongs are a little different). But I have a fairly clear length distinction along with the tense/lax distinction (so my /i/ is clearly much longer than my /ɪ/, for example, and I would transcribe it [iː]). We are using Finegan’s textbook (Language: its structure and use), which presents a variety of I guess you’d call it Standard Average American. At least half of my students are from Texas, though, and have a rather different vowel system. They regularly merge [ɑ] and [ɔ], for example, and there’s quite a bit of monophthongisation of /aɪ/.

This is, of course, an excellent illustration of why IPA is useful, and why orthography doesn’t let you capture differences in pronunciation, but it still adds a lot to the steepness of the learning curve for students who are still pretty new to the idea about thinking about language in this way. When I was an undergrad we just learnt standard Australian English and were graded wrong if, for example, we wrote a w instead of a velarised l for words like “pool”. But I don’t want to teach phonemic transcription when we’re supposed to be doing phonetic transcription! One solution is to do what some of my colleagues do, and do a unit on sociolinguistics and variation first, before the more technical parts of the class, but I don’t want to do that. I like being about to talk about variation and sociolinguistics after they know something about IPA and phonemes and morphology and syntax, because I think it makes it easier to see why linguists talk about socially stigmatised speech varieties as not being “bad speech” or “lazy ways of talking”.


2 responses to “Teaching IPA in a dialectally diverse classroom

  1. I’m all for teaching them to listen to the way they speak. As a beginner student in Canberra, Australia, I got interested in phonetics when I realised that not only were our /l/s different from the Standard American English of our textbook [we’re going back a bit], but also that South Australian syllable-final /l/s and the vowels preceding them were different from those in the eastern Australian states. So, allow them to experiment – get them to compare how they speak with Standard American English -e .g. a dictionary with sound attached. One problem is that I have to be careful to set them examples that they can’t find from looking at the pronunciation field dictionary – so ‘pools’ and ‘pooled’ rather than ‘pool’, and casual speech. Depending on how large the class is, and how much access they have to recording, you can ask them to hand in sound files with the way they speak .

  2. There’s about 80 in the class. I’ve been discouraging access to online dictionaries, because they introduce other transcription conventions (and I didn’t want them looking up the IPA from the American Heritage Dictionary, for example).

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s